atheism, privilege, and the value of truth

An inter­net buddy, Chris Arnade, recently asked what I thought of this piece: “The peo­ple who chal­lenged my athe­ism most were drug addicts and pros­ti­tutes.” My result­ing thoughts turned out to be more than comment-sized, so here we are.

By way of back­ground, Chris has a PhD in physics and worked on Wall Street for a while, but now he spends his time pho­tograph­ing mar­gin­al­ized New York­ers of the Bronx. Basi­cally in the arti­cle,  Chris explains that many of the peo­ple he’s met (the home­less, addicts, pros­ti­tutes, etc) take com­fort in their faith at times when the whole world seems set against them. No par­tic­u­lar sur­prise there. Although Chris him­self is an athe­ist, he finds his opin­ions turn­ing against the arro­gance of the New Athe­ists — as exem­pli­fied by Richard Dawkins — who argue that reli­gious belief is irra­tional and who refuse to tol­er­ant the reli­gious beliefs of oth­ers. Chris writes:

Soon I saw my athe­ism for what it is: An intel­lec­tual belief most acces­si­ble to those who have done well.

And for this, Chris expects me to exco­ri­ate him. I’m not sure that these sub­se­quent com­ments of mine qual­ify as “exco­ri­a­tion,” although I do think Chris’s char­ac­ter­i­za­tion of the sit­u­a­tion is overly sim­pli­fied (in his defense, per­haps nec­es­sar­ily, due to its venue in the pop­u­lar press). I’m per­fectly will­ing to admit that athe­ism is in some respects a man­i­fes­ta­tion of priv­i­lege, by the priv­i­leged. The less you have to worry about just get­ting by, the more emo­tional / finan­cial / cog­ni­tive resources remain for you to engage in truth-seeking… espe­cially in truth-seeking that poten­tially jeop­ar­dizes foun­da­tional beliefs that moti­vate you when the going gets really tough. This is not really a novel obser­va­tion. Poor peo­ple also don’t learn alot of archaic his­tory or poetry, either. It’s just not a priority.

Read More

Suburbs Are Generic, Cities Are Particular

As all of you who fol­low me on any social media out­let already know, I recently took a trip home to the moth­er­land: the sub­urbs of Atlanta, Geor­gia. I lived there from birth (1985) until 2007, when I made a 3-year lay­over in the sub­urbs of Phoenix before finally mov­ing to New York City in 2010. […]

Slut Shaming, Sex Shaming, and Social Norms

Slut sham­ing” has become a topic of peren­nial inter­est in the fem­i­nist blo­gos­phere, but recently it has become an object of atten­tion in the lib­er­tar­ian blo­gos­phere as well. Pre­dictably, sex­ual issues — like fam­ily and repro­duc­tive issues — are divi­sive to lib­er­tar­i­ans. On one side of the spec­trum, we have loud lib­ertines, who find any […]

Don't Go Back To School (part 1)

A few days ago, I had the plea­sure of attend­ing the book release party for Kio Stark’s “Don’t Go Back To School.” I missed the Kick­starter for the book a while back, but saw her speak at a Skill­share con­fer­ence last year, and had sub­scribed to her email list. Some­times going to events full of internet […]

That Time I Got Married

Last week would have marked my 4th wed­ding anniver­sary, had we not divorced. Actu­ally, I sup­pose it’s still the 4th anniver­sary of the wed­ding, although peo­ple tend not to cel­e­brate those occa­sions after they split up, for obvi­ous rea­sons. On May 22nd, 2009, I mar­ried my col­lege boyfriend. I was 23 at the time. It […]

Spend It Out

Frankly I have mixed feel­ings about Gretchen Rubin’s Hap­pi­ness Project. Although it’s a sat­is­fac­tory entry point into what you could call applied pos­i­tive psy­chol­ogy, I find that I actively dis­like many of her “Moment of Hap­pi­ness” quotes of the day (still can’t bring myself to unsub­scribe from the emails though because at least they are […]

"The Start-up of You," or The Future and Its Friends

Last week, I devoured Reid Hoff­man & Ben Cas­nocha’s brand new book, “The Start-up of You: Adapt to the Future, Invest in Your­self, and Trans­form your Career.” It couldn’t have come out at a more appro­pri­ate time for me per­son­ally, given that I have aban­doned aca­d­e­mic aspi­ra­tions, left grad school, quit a bor­ing pub­lish­ing job, […]

Huffington Post!

Dear read­ers, In case you hadn’t seen this on Twit­ter or Face­book or G+ already, just wanted to give you a heads up that I’ll now be shar­ing most of my education-related con­tent over at the Huff­in­g­ton Post. Occa­sional book reviews and other mis­cel­lany will still appear here. Thanks for fol­low­ing! pjs

Putting NH's new alternative curricula law in context

Recently, my good buddy Jason Becker shared this arti­cle with me over here. An excerpt: New Hampshire’s Republican-dominated Leg­is­la­ture over­rode Demo­c­ra­tic Gov. John Lynch’s veto Wednes­day to enact a law let­ting par­ents request an alter­na­tive cur­ricu­lum for any sub­ject they object to, leg­is­la­tion that crit­ics say could limit children’s access to a com­pre­hen­sive and qual­ity edu­ca­tion. H.B. 542 […]

Seligman on happiness: authentic or by definition?

I’m almost done with Mar­tin Seligman’s well-known book of pos­i­tive psy­chol­ogy, Authen­tic Hap­pi­ness (2003). It’s been a very good read — although I was famil­iar with many of the rel­e­vant research find­ings, from my var­i­ous inter­net trav­els (and Bark­ing Up The Wrong Tree in par­tic­u­lar), Selig­man puts it all together and lays it out in […]